“Art Is Useless”

Before we get exercised by this statement by Wilde, we have to understand the proposition he was putting forward. What he was saying is that “Art” has no utilitarian purpose. It exists for itself alone as an expression of beauty, thought, what have you.

Art is not for digging ditches or building houses. And that may be very true, but who can deny that it can inspire men to do things, to take action, to change history. The statement is true and at the same time it is not true. It is not true for the same reason it illustrates another thesis advanced by Wilde. What you see in art, whatever form it takes, does not reflect what you are seeing, hearing, taking in with all your senses. The life it has is what you yourself bring to it with all the potentialities you have. If you see beauty, it is your own capacity to appreciate that, that is awakened in your viewing. If you see evil, it is that capacity in yourself that you recognize in viewing/hearing/ tasting the work of art.

No-one can deny, nevertheless, the capacity of art to inspire all the actions that human beings are capable of.

Needless to say his ideas caused a great deal of heartburn among his contemporaries. The behavior of Dorian Gray in the book, and in a 1945 movie, expressions of homosexuality,  Wilde was arguing, was not in the actions of the characters portrayed in the presentation , but in the confabulations in the minds of the viewers. When Wilde was brought up four years later on charges for acts of “gross indecency”, it put the lie to his assertions.

Yet, what Wilde asserts is patently true. Presentations of art forms achieve their substance and clothing in the perceptions of the viewers. They are works of imagination whatever the fount of inspiration that brought them into being. Unless the author, him or herself acknowledges them as literal products of experience, they achieve their life only in the perceptions of the recipients of the messages being transmitted. They can only have a life if we ourselves have the imagination to conceive what we see and hear.

I think about so much that I have written in the first person and I wonder if I wouldn’t have been much better to have taken Wilde’s thesis to heart. Then I would have had deniability for all my sins.

While I accept the literality of Wilde’s thesis, I believe, along with most of you, in the utility, not to say, the imperative necessity of art to lift us out of ourselves. Yes, and to literally lift us out of our seats of complacency, inertia, and inaction, to defend and advance those things of crucial importance to us when they may be threatened. Time and again, Art, in all its manifold forms, has played a key role in that process. We see this playing out around the world, when people follow symbols, at the risk of their lives, to defend valued things that they believe are threatened.

*This is the final statement made by Oscar Wilde in the Preface of his seminal work The Picture Of Dorian Gray, published in book form in 1891.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

                    Revenge is Good For The Soul Experts in social psychology, experts who treat us when stuff inside our heads go wacky, the people we often turn to, to help us emerge from a blue funk of various kinds, they all talk about how hating is bad for us. They say we are the beneficiaries when we give up harboring these negative feelings about people and events that have caused us pain. They even say we should find it in our hearts to forgive and forget. That may work for some things and for some people. But for me, there are things for which forgive and forget just doesn’t work. That is particularly true when opportunities exist to right the wrongs that have been experienced. And that is particularly true for me when there are opportunities for revenge. Some time ago there was a movie that came out, called “Inglorious Basterds”* It recounts the tale of a Jewish/American commando squad th...
Read more
                                                          ​ Coming To Attention!   Life comes at us from all directions. The nitty-gritty of daily living demands our primary attention, earning a wage, satisfying the boss, meeting a partner’s needs, raising the kids when it’s your turn to show up and be a parent. Then there is the job of keeping up to date with all you need to learn just to do all that. It’s a wonder we take the time to eat and sleep. When do we pay attention to what is going on all around us outside the narrow horizons of our lives? Shouldn’t that be an important element, what we do to impact the larger picture, in determining our fate even though our direct effect on events is often very small? And yet what is going on around us can have an impact on us that can be very large. I am in a very different place right no...
Read more
                            BEING ALIVE We don’t talk about that very much. But we surely think about it. Don’t we do that when we experience particularly joyful moments, or very sad ones? Mundane or marvelous, it is central to what we are about. How can we not think about it, write about it, agonize over it? We tend to keep those thoughts to ourselves unless we are sharing with those who are very close to us. Opening up to our feelings in a public way creates vulnerabilities. We may be laughed at or even ridiculed. It can be so much easier to do with strangers that we will never meet again. It takes more courage to do it face to face with those with whom we share our lives. But we do so with the hope that in exposing our vulnerabilities, we will be shared with in return and our trust will not be abused. There are sensations of being alive that are almost im...
Read more